Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
Debating in a city where rising sea levels are a concern, Hillary Clinton suggested Bernie Sanders wants to set back a major climate change policy of the Obama administration.
"The Clean Power Plan is something that Sen. Sanders has said he would delay implementing, which makes absolutely no sense," Clinton said.
"What? Tsk," Sanders said, laughing and shaking his head incredulously.
"Wait, what?" was our reaction too.
Looking at statements and actions by Sanders, Clinton’s statement is misleading.
Briefly, the Clean Power Plan aims to cut carbon emissions from coal-burning power plants by 2030 by 32 percent from 2005 levels, promoting clean(er) energy sources instead. This plan, hailed and criticized as a historic environmental initiative, was put on hold on Feb. 9, 2016, by the U.S. Supreme Court.
We searched Google, LexisNexis and CQ for comments Sanders has made on the plan and found no evidence that Sanders has said he wants to delay the implementation.
The Clinton campaign referred us to Sanders’ Feb. 21 interview with Grist, an environmental online magazine, in which he laid out what President Sanders would likely do on climate change.
Sanders said he would change the Clean Power Plan to incentivize renewables instead of gas and extend a two-year program for wind and solar credits all the way to 2030. And beyond carbon, he would also regulate methane through the plan.
The Clinton campaign also cited environmental law expert Richard Revesz’s blog post for The Hill criticizing Sanders. The Clean Power Plan "cannot be changed at the stroke of the pen," Revesz wrote a few days after the Grist interview, and Sanders’ actions would "stop the train and cause a great delay."
(Ann Carlson, an environmental law professor, made the same argument.)
But Sanders himself did not say he would delay implementation. In reality, he wants a more ambitious plan (and has released one) and has supported Obama’s plan from the get-go.
A day before it was unveiled, Sanders said in a press release, "It sounds to me like a step forward in ending our dependence on fossil fuel, and I support that effort."
He also tweeted that day, "Pres Obama knows climate change is the great planetary crisis facing us & we must move boldly to transform our energy system #CleanPowerPlan."
"It is an embarrassment that with few exceptions Republicans refuse to recognize the reality of climate change, and even fewer are prepared to do anything about it," he wrote in a press release following the effort to repeal the plan. "Today’s vote to block the Clean Power Plan is a stark reminder that instead of worrying about the future of our planet, Republicans are more concerned with their campaign contributions."
Clinton said, "The Clean Power Plan is something that Sen. Sanders has said he would delay implementing."
Sanders advocates for more ambitious action on climate change, which some experts argue could delay the plan. But Sanders himself has never said what Clinton is suggesting, and he has supported the Clean Power Act in words and action.
We rate Clinton’s claim False.
Email interview with Nick Merrill, spokesperson for Hillary Clinton March 10, 2016
Grist, "6 things Bernie Sanders would do to crack down on fracking, even if Congress doesn’t go along," Feb. 21, 2016
The Hill, "Sanders shouldn't hit 'reset' on Clean Power Plan," Feb. 26, 2016
Sanders.Senate.Gov, "Sanders Statement on Effort to Repeal Clean Power Plan," Nov. 17, 2015
League of Conservation Voters, "IN THEIR OWN WORDS 2016 PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATES ON THE CLEAN POWER PLAN," March 3, 2016
Twitter, Bernie Sanders, Aug. 2, 2015
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.