Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
Republican Duf Sundheim started on the attack at Tuesday’s debate in San Diego among five candidates vying to be California’s next U.S. senator.
But the GOP hopeful missed hard on a fact about the state’s violent crime rate. He used his opening remarks to criticize the race’s frontrunner, Democratic California Attorney General Kamala Harris.
"The PPIC (Public Policy Institute of California) recently reported that Kamala is failing to keep us safe," Sundheim said May 10, 2016. "There is a 34 percent increase in violent crime in the state of California. … And that’s just within the last year."
The PPIC, a nonpartisan think tank, reported no such thing.
What the PPIC said
The PPIC report cited by Sundheim doesn’t include final statewide violent crime data for 2015. It has preliminary statistics for January to June 2015 for 66 California cities covering about half of the state’s population.
Brandon Martin, the co-author of the report and a research associate at the policy institute, told PolitiFact California that statewide crime statistics for 2015 won’t be available until this summer.
Moreoever, Sundheim misstated the preliminary data that the PPIC did have.
The authors of the report said 34 of the 66 California cities saw a double-digit percentage increase in violent crimes.
They never claimed that the state, or even the sample of cities, saw a 34 percent increase in violent crime.
"I have not seen any data showing a 34 percent increase in crime in California in 2015. He made a mistake," Magnus Lofstrum, the study’s author and a senior fellow at PPIC, told PolitiFact California.
The most recent full-year crime stats, from 2014, put the state’s violent crime rate at a 47-year low, according to the PPIC.
A spokeswoman for Sundheim’s campaign said, "Looking at the study, the wording is vague and our researchers believed that the '34' was in reference to the percent rise in violent crime."
Sundheim said California’s violent crime rate increased 34 percent over the past year, citing a recent report.
Sundheim misread the report in question, its authors said.
We rate his claim False.
FALSE – The statement is not accurate.
Click here for more on the six PolitiFact ratings and how we select facts to check.
Duf Sundheim, statement in US Senate debate in San Diego, May 10, 2016
Public Policy Institute of California, "Preliminary Data Show Higher Crime Rates in 2015," February 17, 2016
Interview, Magnus Lofstrum, PPIC research fellow and author of "Preliminary Data Show Higher Crime Rates in 2015," May 10, 2016
Interview, Brandon Martin, PPIC research associate and co-author of "Preliminary Data Show Higher Crime Rates in 2015," May 10, 2016
Interview, Sara Lee, campaign spokeswoman for Duf Sundheim, May 10, 2016
Interview, Nathan Click, campaign spokesman for Kamala Harris, May 10, 2016
Public Policy Institute of California, "Crime Trends in California," accessed May 10, 2016
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.