Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
Donald Trump sounded off a scary Halloween message about Hillary Clinton and the latest developments in her email controversy, which he dubbed "the biggest scandal since Watergate."
"As you know, the FBI has reopened its investigation into Hillary Clinton and discovered — you heard this yesterday, it’s hard to believe — and discovered another 650,000 emails. Hillary lied under oath when she said she turned over all of her work-related emails – just one more lie out of so many," Trump said at a Oct. 31 campaign stop in Michigan.
Trump is referring to FBI Director James Comey’s Oct. 28 letter informing Congress that the bureau is looking to examine new evidence potentially relevant to Clinton’s case. But his description is slightly misleading, and the letter did not say anything about the amount of emails involved.
First, the FBI didn’t exactly "reopen" the investigation, as it wasn’t formally closed. We can certainly say the FBI is looking into a case that had previously been inactive.
Trump is less accurate when he suggests the FBI has discovered hundreds of thousands of new emails relevant to the Clinton case. The number, given to the Wall Street Journal by unnamed sources, refers to the total number of emails found in a separate investigation. It’s unclear how many actually pertain to Clinton and how many are actually new.
The 650,000 emails
As PolitiFact has reported, unnamed FBI officials told journalists that the new focus began when the FBI found emails on a laptop seized from former New York congressman Anthony Weiner, who is under investigation for allegedly exchanging sexually explicit messages with a 15-year-old girl. Weiner is separated from Huma Abedin, a longtime aide to Clinton.
Investigators found a total of 650,000 emails on Weiner’s laptop, anonymous sources told the Wall Street Journal. But it remains to be seen how many of those emails involve Clinton, how many are work-related, how many are duplicates of emails already reviewed by the FBI and whether they contain classified information.
The Journal goes on to say that "thousands" could have been sent to or from Clinton’s email server. The Washington Post reported that there are more than 1,000 from the server (though it’s unclear if that refers to the number of threads or individual emails).
A reopened case?
Trump, and other Republicans, have said the FBI has "reopened" the investigation into Clinton, while the Clinton camp and others reject that characterization, pointing out neither Comey’s three-paragraph letter to Congress nor a memo he sent to FBI employees uses the word.
On one level, this is a bit of semantic quibbling. Former FBI officials told us "reopening" is an imprecise word choice, but it gets at the gist of the latest development. It is likely that the FBI had not administratively closed the Clinton case, though it was no longer an active investigation.
On another level, experts told the word "reopens" could imply that officials have found a smoking gun, but that conclusion is premature.
FBI cases are "opened," per management assessment, when there is sufficient information for an investigation. They are "closed," also per a management decision, when there is no more investigative or administrative work to be done.
"Opening and closing a case is really a matter of preparing an internal communication setting forth the reasons for doing so and having the supervisory chain of command agree with that decision," said Nancy Savage, who served in the FBI for 35 years as a special agent and as a management official.
Clearly, the Clinton email investigation (as well as the Weiner case) was officially opened.
But while Comey shared the results of the Clinton email investigation in July 2016, "Comey had not indicated that the Clinton email case was ever formally closed," said Mark Pollitt, a former FBI special agent and director who now teaches at Syracuse University.
"Given the size and scope of the case, I would be surprised it all the paperwork was done yet," Pollitt said. He pointed out that the Clinton investigation had to be active in order for the FBI to obtain a warrant to search Weiner’s emails for Clinton-related exchanges.
So essentially, the case was "reopened" in the sense that the FBI "moved from the administrative wind-up stage back into the active investigative stage," Savage said.
Finally, experts cautioned against reading too much into this new development.
"There is nothing unusual about this investigation being pursued. It is standard operating procedure," Savage said, adding that Comey simply notified Congress that there was new information that required further investigation. "The FBI more than likely did not know and still does not know what all the information means on this computer, which should have (been) turned over much earlier by Abedin."
"The act of reopening a case does not point to any conclusions and is an administrative action within the scope of the earlier review of emails," said Ellen Glasser, a former FBI special agent and supervisor. "Any suggestion that there is a smoking gun, based solely on reopening the case, would be incorrect."
Trump said, "The FBI has reopened its investigation into Hillary Clinton ... and discovered another 650,000 emails."
Trump has a point that the FBI had stopped actively investigating Clinton emails until the latest development. But experts told us it’s unlikely it was ever formally closed, so "reopen" is an imprecise word.
The bigger factual issue is his number. The 650,000 emails were discovered in a separate investigation, and it is not clear just how many are related to Clinton and how many are duplicates of emails already reviewed by the FBI. Reports indicate that the bureau is examining just a small portion of the 650,000 emails.
We rate Trump’s claim Half True.
Youtube, Donald Trump Speech in Grand Rapid, Michigan, Oct. 31, 2016
PolitiFact, "Hillary Clinton’s latest email controversy, what we know," Oct. 30, 2016
Wall Street Journal, "FBI in Internal Feud Over Hillary Clinton Probe," Oct. 30, 2016
Washington Post, "Computer seized in Weiner probe prompts FBI to take new steps in Clinton email inquiry," Oct. 28, 2016
New York Times, "F.B.I. Begins Review of Clinton Aide’s Emails," Oct. 31, 2016
NBC, "FBI Working to Winnow Through Emails From Anthony Weiner's Laptop," Oct. 31, 2016
Email interview with Nancy Savage, executive director of the Society of Former Special Agents of the FBI, Nov. 1, 2016
Email interview with Mark Pollitt, adjunct professor at Syracuse University, Oct. 31, 2016
Email interview with Ellen Glasser, instructor at the University of North Florida, Nov. 1, 2016
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.