Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
For the aging and those with long-term care needs, receiving care at home is more affordable than institutionalized facilities like hospitals or nursing homes. But presidential candidate John Delaney argued on Twitter that even with jobs growing in the home care industry, workers are struggling with low wages because "most of home care is paid by government programs, which don’t pay enough."
Is home care really funded mostly by government programs? We decided to check.
Delaney, a former Maryland congressman, got his numbers from a factsheet from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, his campaign spokesperson Will McDonald told PolitiFact. The factsheet stated that "Medicare and Medicaid together made up 76 percent of home health spending in 2017."
Medicare paid a total of $38.7 billion, followed by Medicaid, which paid for over $35 billion, according to the 2017 data. Government programs, including Medicaid, Medicare, Department of Veteran Affairs programs, state and local programs, and the Children’s Health Insurance Program spent $75.2 billion on home health care. Together, they add up to 78% of total home health care spending.
Most of the money spent on home health care went to skilled medical care. However, those numbers don’t capture another big part of the spending on care at home: long-term, non-medical unskilled care.
This unskilled care includes things like assistance with bathing, cooking, eating, using the toilet, dressing, shopping, and chores. These services are usually for seniors and people with illness and disabilities.
Medicare, for instance, only covers short-term, intermittent unskilled care concurrently with the medical care people receive from therapists and nurses, for less than 8 hours a day up to a period of 60 days, according to the government. That’s part of Medicare’s home health spending of $38.7 billion in 2017.
But for long-term unskilled care, Medicare doesn’t pay at all.
And Medicaid pays for long-term unskilled care only in some cases.
Excluding medical care, Medicaid spent $76.9 billion on home and community-based long-term care in fiscal 2017, a survey of Medicaid programs by the Kaiser Family Foundation suggested.
"Medicaid is the only program that covers some of this non-medical long-term care under certain circumstances for people who have spent down their assets", said Ani Turner, co-director of Sustainable Health Spending Strategies at Altarum, a nonprofit research organization.
Long-term unskilled care at home is paid for by out-of-pocket private payers, long-term care insurance, or by Medicaid, for those who qualify based on states’ eligibility standards for low income, said Regina Shih, Ph.D., Senior Policy Researcher at the non-profit RAND Corporation, who studies Long-Term Services and Supports.
How much is spent on long-term unskilled care at home by all payers? We don’t know.
Despite a booming private home care industry, "the full size and range of private pay just hasn't really been captured," Spillman said.
For the elderly who are not institutionalized, government programs pay less than 30% of their home and community care bills. A Department of Health and Human Services policy brief estimated that people turning 65 between 2015 and 2019 will pay 68.6% of their home or residential care costs out-of-pocket.
Still, Delaney made a valid point about wages, experts said. "Since the government is paying for a large share of home health care services," Turner said, "the reimbursement rates paid under these government programs strongly influence what home health agencies can afford to pay their workers."
There's one final point to consider when we tabulate the dollars spent on in-home care. Formally reported spending on long-term services and support underestimates total expenditures, noted the report by the Congressional Research Service. A lot of non-medical in-home care was shouldered by family caregivers, who are often uncompensated, said Shih.
"This reliance on unpaid caregivers while governments are trying to curb (Long-Term Services and Supports) costs is why caring for older adults and those with disability in our nation is a crisis," Shih said.
Delaney said that "Most of home care is paid by government programs."
Medicaid, Medicare, CHIP are the largest payers of total medical care at home. However, the current data doesn’t capture the mix of spending that includes long-term non-medical home care, for things like shopping, bathing and other everyday chores.
Based on the available data, we rate this statement Mostly True.
John Delaney, Twitter, April 13, 2019
Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, National Health Expenditures 2017 Highlights, Accessed April 16, 2019
Email interview with Regina Shih, Ph.D., Senior Policy Researcher at the RAND Corporation, April 17, 2019
Email interview with Paul Osterman, Co-Director of Sloan Institute for Work and Employment Research, MIT, April 1
Email interview with Ani Turner, Co-Director of Sustainable Health Spending Strategies at Altarum, Aril 17, 2019
Interview with MaryBeth Musumeci, Associate Director of Program on Medicaid and the Uninsured at Kaiser Family Foundation, April 18, 2019
Email interview with Brenda Spillman, Senior Fellow at The Urban Institute, April 18, 2019
Email interview with Bill Marton, Director of Division of Disability and Aging Policy, April 19, 2019
Congressional Research Service, Who Pays for Long-Term Services and Supports? Aug. 22, 2018
Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, National Health Expenditure Accounts, 2017
Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, Medicare & Home Health Care booklet, Accessed April 17, 2019
Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, National Health, Expenditure Accounts: Methodology Paper, 2017
Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, What are my other long-term care choices, Accessed April 22, 2019
Department of Health & Human Services, Long-Term Services and Supports for Older Americans: Risks and Financing Research Brief, Revised February 2016
Kaiser Family Foundation, "Medicaid Home and Community-Based Services Enrollment and Spending", April 18, 2019
PHI, U.S. Home Care Workers: Key Facts, Accessed April 17, 2019
IBM Watson Health, Medicaid Expenditures for Long-Term Services and Supports in FY 2016, 2016
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.