U.S. Sen. Kamala Harris has made equal pay a centerpiece of her Democratic campaign for president.
A few days after launching the proposal, Harris appeared on CBS’s "Late Show with Stephen Colbert." During the interview, Harris discussed her efforts to promote equal pay. Here’s an exchange from the May 22 show, starting about two-thirds of the way through the clip:
Harris: "The law says that men and women should be paid equally for equal work, but what we know is that in America today, women on average are paid 80 cents on the dollar of what men are paid for the same work. African American women, 61 cents on the dollar, Latinas 53 cents on the dollar. And these are actually not debatable points."
Colbert: "So this is not hours worked, on average. This is hour for hour."
Harris: "Yeah, and for the same work. Or it could be the annual salary, but it’s for the same work."
Harris’ figures for African American women and Latinas are correct, as long as you compare those groups to white, non-Hispanic men working full-time and year-round, a distinction that Harris didn’t specify.
However, there’s a bigger problem with what Harris said — that women are paid 80 cents on the dollar of what men are paid "for the same work."
In a nutshell, Harris incorrectly explained the meaning of the gender wage gap. The 80 percent figure is not an apples-to-apples comparison of men and women performing the same work. Instead, it refers to average pay for all jobs held by men and all jobs held by women.
When we reached out to the Harris campaign, they quickly acknowledged that Harris had misspoken, even after being prodded on the point by Colbert. Spokesman Ian Sams pointed out that Harris’ plan does not use the "for the same work" formulation.
The most recent official data on this point, published by the U.S. Census Bureau for 2017, showed that women earned 80.5 percent of what men did. That’s up by a couple percentage points in recent years, though it did not significantly change between 2016 and 2017.
As we’ve written previously, the 80 percent figure does not adjust for such factors as the degrees and jobs women pursue, the time they take off to care for children, the number of hours they work, and the years of experience they’ve had.
So while the 80 percent figure may be used to signify some facets of women’s challenges in the workplace — such as disproportionate representation in fields that offer more flexible work schedules, even if that means earning less — the statistic cannot be used to pinpoint pay discrimination between men and women doing the same work.
Other studies have shown a significantly closer match for men and women holding the same jobs.
For instance, a 2013 study by the American Association of University Women that evened out those factors found a 7 percent wage gap between men and women a year after graduating college.
That’s still a disparity, but it’s about one-third as big as the figure Harris cited in her tweet.
"Adjusting for workers’ hours of work narrows the gender gap below the gap mentioned by Sen. Harris," said Gary Burtless, an economist with the Brookings Institution. "Adjusting for workers’ age, educational attainment, and years of work experience also reduces the gap slightly. Making additional adjustments for workers’ industry, occupation, and size of employer reduces the gap even more."
While career choices may be shaped to a certain extent by gender, "we do not know how much discriminatory ‘herding’ there is," he said.
It’s worth noting that the wage gap varies industry-by-industry. For instance, women working as cooks earn about 91 percent of what male cooks make, but women in retail sales earn just 74 percent of what their male equivalents earn, according to calculations by the Institute for Women’s Policy Research.
In an article for the job site Indeed.com in May 2019, economist Martha Gimbel cited research suggesting that "occupation and industry differences between men and women explain about half of the gender pay gap because men are more likely to work in occupations with higher pay."
Harris said, "In America today, women on average are paid 80 cents on the dollar of what men are paid for the same work."
The 80 percent figure compares pay for all working women to pay for all working men, so it’s wrong for Harris to characterize it as a comparison between women and men doing the same work. Research has shown a pay gap for women and men doing the same work, but it’s narrower than 80 cents on the dollar.
We rate the statement Mostly False.
Kamala Harris, appearance on CBS’ "Late Show with Stephen Colbert," May 22, 2019
U.S. Census Bureau, "Income and Poverty in the United States: 2017," Sept. 12, 2018
Kamala Harris campaign, "Holding Corporations Accountable for Pay Inequality in America," accessed May 23, 2019
CNN, "Harris unveils plan to fine companies that don't achieve pay equity," May 20, 2019
Indeed.com, "These Jobs Have the Most Unequal Pay," May 2, 2019
National Partnership for Women and Families, "America’s Women and the Wage Gap," May 2019
National Partnership for Women and Families, "Quantifying America’s Gender Wage Gap by Race/Ethnicity," April 2019
Institute for Women’s Policy Research, "The Gender Wage Gap by Occupation 2017 and by Race and Ethnicity," April 9, 2018
PolitiFact, "Do women get only 80 percent of the pay men do for the same job?" April 13, 2018
PolitiFact, "Fact-checking median pay for black, Hispanic, Native American women," May 16, 2019
Email interview with Gary Burtless, Brookings Institution economist, May 23, 2019
Email interview with Tara Sinclair, economist at George Washington University, May 23, 2019
Email interview with Ian Sams, spokesman for Kamala Harris, May 23, 2019
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.