Get PolitiFact in your inbox.
If Your Time is short
- This video clip from 2020 shows migrants reacting after Greek authorities fired tear gas on them, according to multiple news reports.
As people walk and run in the background, and smoke wafts through the trees, a man can be seen in a video clip holding a child over a fire, rubbing the toddler’s back while a woman next to them wails and flaps her hands by her face. The crying of others can be heard in the background. The scene is chaotic.
But according to a 2020 Facebook post that’s getting fresh attention, it’s staged.
"When we say fake news … there was double meaning behind, ‘the whole world is a stage,’" the caption on the post says. "This isn’t just local … this is world wide. … Illegal migrants are deliberately shaking young children in order for them to cry in front of the cameras in Greece and throughout Europe."
Though the video is nearly three years old, it’s attracting new viewers and comments, including suggestions that the war in Ukraine is staged and that the video shows a "film set."
This post was flagged as part of Facebook’s efforts to combat false news and misinformation on its News Feed. (Read more about our partnership with Meta, which owns Facebook and Instagram.)
Searching online for evidence to corroborate this claim, we found other similar allegations, also unsourced, and lots of speculation, but no evidence that the person in the video is trying to make a child cry for reporters.
We found plenty of evidence that the video shows people dealing with the aftermath of tear gas.
The footage was posted on YouTube by Turkish public broadcaster TRT World on March 3, 2020.
"Greek security forces are using tear gas on refugees and migrants, including young children, in an attempt to stop them from entering the country," the caption says.
Some people commenting on both the Facebook post and YouTube video suggested that the man was holding the child over the smoking fire to alleviate tear gas.
Other news outlets shared similar footage in 2020 of tear gas fired by Greek authorities to try to keep migrants from crossing from Turkey into Greece. Sky News posted a clip on YouTube of a woman dabbing bottle water on the eyes of a sobbing child.
"Migrants blasted with tear gas at Turkey, Greece border," a Feb. 29, 2020, New York Post headline said alongside a photo of people carrying children and luggage, covering their mouths.
We rate claims that this video shows migrants faking distress for news cameras False.
Facebook post, March 2, 2020
TRT World, Greek forces fire tear gas at refugees and migrants, March 3, 2020
France24, Exclusive: Migrants face tear gas, violence at Greek-Turkish border, March 7, 2020
Agence France-Presse, Turkey: Tear gas fired to push migrants away from Greece border | AFP, Feb. 29, 2020
DW News, Greek police fire tear gas at migrants on Turkish border | DW News, Feb. 29, 2020
CBC, Greek and Turkish police fire tear gas as migrants try to cross into Greece, March 4, 2020
Reuters, Greek, Turkish police fire tear gas as migrant border crisis deepens, March 4, 2020
Getty Images, Topshot-Turkey-Greece-EU-migrants-conflict, Feb. 29, 2020
New York Post, Migrants blasted with tear gas at Turkey, Greece border, Feb. 29, 2020
Sky News, Refugees face tear gas on Turkish border, Feb. 29, 2020
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.