Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
If Your Time is short
The Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) is a loan that’s aimed at incentivizing businesses to keep workers on their payroll during the coronavirus pandemic.
The Facebook post correctly characterizes how Kanye West, Jared Kushner’s family and Rep. Roger Williams are connected to companies that received money from that program.
However, the post oversimplifies how Elaine Chao, Brad Parscale, Betsy DeVos and Devin Nunes benefited.
A popular Facebook post claims that some wealthy Republicans and other public figures have benefited from the federal government’s $2 trillion coronavirus relief package.
The post, which was published July 7 by a page called Feminist News, includes a collage of photos depicting eight public figures. It claims that businesses ranging from Kanye West’s apparel company, Yeezy, to "Devin Nunes’ winery" have received loans through the Paycheck Protection Program.
"All these millionaires got millions (or close to it) in PPP loans while tens of millions of Americans got a bullsh*t $1200 check months ago," reads text in the collage. "This is how a mafia state works. The small inner circle gets rewarded. Everyone else suffers."
The post was flagged as part of Facebook’s efforts to combat false news and misinformation on its News Feed. (Read more about our partnership with Facebook.) It has been shared more than 50,000 times, and other popular liberal pages have published similar posts.
(Screenshot from Facebook)
The Paycheck Protection Program is a federal loan initiative to encourage businesses to keep workers on their payrolls during the coronavirus pandemic. The loans are forgivable, meaning some recipients may be able to keep the money. It passed as part of a larger legislative package in late March and was extended by President Donald Trump on July 4.
Two days later, the Small Business Administration and the Treasury Department released a dataset with details about the millions of loans awarded to businesses and nonprofits so far. We used that data to take a closer look at the Facebook post.
The post is correct in saying that some businesses connected to prominent Republicans have received money as part of the program. But in some cases the post oversimplifies their connection to those businesses, and the data do not show that each person personally received "millions (or close to it)."
Some of the Republicans mentioned in the Facebook post directly benefited from PPP loans. Others own stakes in PPP beneficiary companies or have more indirect relationships.
The loan database released by the SBA and the Treasury Department does not specify exactly how much money each entity received. Instead, it offers wide ranges.
We took a look at the database, as well as news reports, to see how each person mentioned in the Facebook post is connected to PPP beneficiaries. (Search the database for yourself here.)
What the post says: "Kanye West’s company, Yeezy"
Who got the money: Yeezy LLC
Prior to a July 8 interview in which he said he is no longer supporting the president, West was one of Trump’s biggest celebrity supporters. According to the PPP loan database, Yeezy received between $2 million and $5 million.
What the post says: "Jared Kushner’s family"
Who got the money: Several companies wholly or partially owned by the Kushners
Observer Holdings LLC, the parent company of Observer Media — which Kushner used to run and is currently owned by his brother-in-law’s investment firm — received between $350,000 and $1 million.
A company called Princeton Forrestal LLC — 40%-owned by Kushner relatives, according to a 2018 securities filing analyzed by the Daily Beast — received between $1 million and $2 million.
Esplanade Livingston LLC, a company connected to the Kushners, received between $350,000 and $1 million.
The Joseph Kushner Hebrew Academy in Livingston, N.J., received between $1 million and $2 million. It was named after Kushner’s grandfather and is supported by the family.
Hollwich Kushner Architecture, a firm headed by Marc Kushner, Jared Kushner’s first cousin, received between $150,000 and $350,000.
What the posts: "Mitch McConnell’s wife, Elaine Chao"
Who got the money: The Foremost Group LLC
Chao is the U.S. transportation secretary. A shipping business run by her family benefited from the PPP. The Foremost Group received between $350,000 and $1 million, according to the loan database. Contrary to what the Facebook post says, Chao herself did not receive a loan.
The Foremost Group is not listed on Chao’s 2017 financial disclosure, but her relationship with the company has been the subject of a House of Representatives ethics investigation. The Facebook post notes she is married to Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky.
What the post says: "Trump’s campaign manager’s company"
Who got the money: CloudCommerce Inc.
CloudCommerce, a digital marketing company whose largest shareholder is Brad Parscale, Trump’s campaign manager, received between $350,000 and $1 million from the PPP, according to CBS News and the loan database.
Between 2017 and 2018, CloudCommerce acquired several of Parscale’s companies, and he joined the company’s board of directors. On Dec. 10, 2019, Parscale resigned from the board, but he retained his 34.9% stake in CloudCommerce, according to a Securities and Exchange Commission filing.
As of that date, Parscale was not a "director, officer, employee or contractor" of the company, according to the filing. The current chairman and CEO of CloudCommerce is Andrew Van Noy.
Van Noy told CBS that Parscale "no longer has any involvement in decision-making for the company, including the PPP loan." Neither Parscale Properties LLC, an investment company that Parscale set up with his family, nor Parscale Strategy LLC, a company that was set up by Parscale and has billed millions to the Trump campaign and the Republican National Committee, has received money from the program.
What the post says: "Trump’s super PAC"
Who got the money: Companies that have donated to a pro-Trump super PAC
A pro-Trump super PAC did not receive money from the PPP.
Vital Pharmaceuticals, the company that owns Bang Energy, was lent between $5 million and $10 million. In 2019, Vital Pharmaceuticals gave $250,000 to America First Action, a pro-Trump super PAC that spent $36 million during the 2018 campaign cycle, according to OpenSecrets.org. Another firm that has donated to the super PAC, G.H. Palmer Associates, received between $350,000 and $1 million, according to the loan database and CNBC.
Companies connected to other major Trump donors were among the earliest recipients of PPP loans, the Associated Press reported.
What the post says: Betsy DeVos
Who got the money: Renaissance Acquisition Co. LLC
The education secretary herself did not receive a loan, but the Facebook post framed it that way. Bloomberg reported that a company with the same name as one listed on her 2017 financial disclosure report did. Renaissance Acquisition Co., which operates an Indianapolis-based company that provides services to nonprofits, received between $2 million and $5 million, according to the loan database.
In her financial disclosure, DeVos reported earning $216,600 as a distributive share from Renaissance Acquisition, meaning she is a partial owner or partner in the business.
What the post says: "Devin Nunes’ winery"
Who got the money: Phase 2 Cellars LLC and Alpha Omega Winery LLC
Rep. Nunes, R-Calif., is not the sole owner of Phase 2 Cellars, a vineyard in San Luis Obispo that received between $1 million and $2 million from the PPP. But he is a partial owner, holding between $50,001 and $100,000 in equity in it, according to a Daily Beast analysis of Nunes’ most recent financial disclosure. Alpha Omega Winery, another California vineyard in which Nunes holds equity, received a loan within the same range.
What the post says: "Rep. Roger Williams, R-Texas"
Who got the money: JRW Corp.
JRW Corp., a Fort Worth, Texas, car dealership where Williams serves as the sole director and president, was lent between $1 million and $2 million. His own stake in the company exceeds $50 million, according to Williams’ most recent financial disclosure.
We reached out to Feminist News for a comment, but we haven’t heard back.
A Facebook post says eight wealthy public figures received loans as part of the federal Paycheck Protection Program.
The post correctly characterizes how West, Kushner and Williams are connected to companies that received money. However, it oversimplifies how Chao, Parscale, DeVos and Nunes benefited from the program.
The federal government lent millions of dollars to companies connected to, but not wholly owned by, Parscale, Nunes and DeVos. A shipping company owned by Chao’s family received between $350,000 and $1 million, but she did not receive a loan herself, and the company is not listed on her financial disclosure.
The Facebook post is partially accurate but leaves out important details or takes things out of context. We rate it Half True.
ABC News, "Trump team defends 2020 campaign manager's compensation," Aug. 23, 2019
Associated Press, "Trump donors among early recipients of coronavirus loans," July 7, 2020
Bloomberg, Renaissance Acquisition Holdings LLC, accessed July 9, 2020
Bloomberg, "Trump’s Waikiki Partner, Kushner Family Among PPP Borrowers," July 6, 2020
CBS News, "Company tied to Trump campaign manager gets PPP loan," May 14, 2020
Clerk of the House of Representatives, Financial Disclosure Report: Devin Nunes, 2019
Clerk of the House of Representatives, Financial Disclosure Report: Roger Williams, 2019
CloudCommerce, About page, accessed July 9, 2020
CNBC, "Companies with Trump ties got coronavirus small business loans," July 7, 2020
Congress.gov, H.R.748 - CARES Act
The Daily Beast, "Trump’s Small Biz Rescue Bailed Out Kushner’s Family, Obama’s Aides and Other Political Elite," July 6, 2020
Facebook post, July 7, 2020
Facebook post, July 8, 2020
Facebook post, July 8, 2020
Fox Business, "Trump extends PPP deadline with $130B left in small business fund," July 4, 2020
Office of Government Ethics, Public Financial Disclosure Report (OGE Form 278e): Betsy DeVos, 2017
Office of Government Ethics, Public Financial Disclosure Report (OGE Form 278e): Elaine Chao, 2017
OpenCorporates, HWKN ARCHITECTURE D.P.C., accessed July 9, 2020
OpenCorporates, PARSCALE PROPERTIES LLC, accessed July 10, 2020
OpenSecrets.org, America First Action, accessed July 10, 2020
OpenSecrets.org, "Company that gave six figures to pro-Trump super PAC got PPP loan worth at least $5 million," July 7, 2020
OpenSecrets.org, GH Palmer Assoc, accessed July 13, 2020
OpenSecrets.org, Vendor/Recipient Profile: Parscale Strategy, accessed July 10, 2020
ProPublica, Coronavirus Bailouts, accessed July 9, 2020
ProPublica, "Trump Friends and Family Cleared for Millions in Small Business Bailout," July 6, 2020
Securities Exchange Commission, EDGAR, accessed July 10, 2020
Securities Exchange Commission, Form 10-K: CloudCommerce, Inc., April 16, 2020
Small Business Administration, Paycheck Protection Program, accessed July 8, 2020
Small Business Administration, "SBA and Treasury Announce Release of PPP Loan Data," July 6, 2020
Vanity Fair, "Devin Nunes’ Winery, Kushner Family Business Raked In Coronavirus Relief Money," July 7, 2020
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.